Assessing Assessments

The resources i still need to get:
1. More articles out of Mauk & Mets
2. Some of the sources i provided won't help me so i should find ones that will

Have i assessed my resources effectively?
- Probably not, i should take another look at them.

Resource Reflextion

1. How did you find your resources?
- I found most of them on google! Except for my interview (my sister)...she wasn't hard to find. She lives in my house. The book i found on the SJSU database website for the library. I later went to the library and found it to see what it was all about. The video, newspaper, journal, and magazine i just found on google like i said earlier.

2. How has research altered your original idea?
- It's given me insight on both sides of my thesis, it's given me more info on it than altered it Its given me opinions which are going to be very important in my paper.

Book Assessment (Facebook)

 Online social networking

 Sylvia Engdahl, book editor.

 Farmington Hills, MI : Greenhaven Press, c2007.

This book is all about how social networks are a bad influence on kids and how parents should limit the usage of them. It bashes some websites like myspace and facebook by telling you there are sexual predators that find victims through online social networking and pornographers that expose children to obscenity at online social networking sites. Overall this book pretty much hates social networks and gives a one sided view. It talks nothing of the good things about social networks, only the bad. But it is authoritative because it was in the library and gives lots of info on the topic. I would use this in a paper about social networking if i wanted to see the bad side of myspace, facebook, ext. 

Personal Interview (Facebook)

For my interview i interviewed my sister:

Me: How often do you use facebook?
Sister: I check it on my free time, to see if my friends have left me a comment or anything.

Me: What do you like/dislike about it?
Sister: I like that i can communicate with my friends easily on it and that it doesn't take much to do it. I dislike that i don't always know who's looking at my profile.

Me: How did you begin to use facebook?
Sister: A friend made one for me, i didn't like it at first but i grew on me.

Me: Do you find it easier to communicate with friends now?
Sister:Definitely, i can see whats going on with them and leave comments for them to see later.

Me: Do you feel facebook is a good thing for college students?
Sister: I do, college students are very busy so its nice to have facebook and other social networks to be able to communicate with my friends quickly.

Me: Are you comfortable with people you don't really know looking at comments and pictures of you?
Sister: Not at all, i wish there was more security features on it.

Video Assessment (Facebook)

Although this video is obviously a joke it bring up good points in it's lyrics:

• "Theres an online world where I am king of a little website dedicated to me" - This is one of the reasons why facebook and myspace are so popular, its that persons own little space where they are "king". The personal nature of these social networks are very appealing to some.

• "Before the Internet friendship was so tough, you actually had to be in peoples presence and stuff" - Also a good point to the affects of social networks, people become less accustom to actually meeting with people face to face. Social networks to a certain extent make people lazy by people having mostly an online relationship with friends and having the Internet be the main way of communication.

• "I used to meet girls hangin out at the mall, now I just wait for them to write on my wall." -This is a sad but true statement about how some people are today. Again bringing the laziness point up.

• "If the internet crashed all across the land,or my facebook account was deleted by the man. Id carry around a picture of my face and a summary of me typed out on a page" -The song pokes fun also at what would happen if facebook went down, they said they would carry a picture of themselves around with a summery typed out. This wouldn't happen obviously but i think if facebook or other social networks went down people wouldn't know what to do, they have become so use to a online way of communication.

Overall this video is very humerus and bring up a lot of good points in it through the lyrics and graphics. These are not professionals that did this just regular people but i still think it would be very useful in writing a paper. The points they bring up in a comedic why would fit well into my paper. It may not be "authoritative" because it is from youtube and made by some dudes but informative non the less.

Newspaper Article Assessment (Facebook)

Facebook
Brad Stone, Dec. 7, 2007; updated Feb. 18, 2009

This New York Times article is not too interesting because it does not have an opinion but only states the facts like most of the other articles I've read about facebook. Its boring but still is a authoritative source because new york times is a major paper with respected journalists. It talks about the history of facebook from the beginning to the present and how it has quickly become a part of social networking. The article focuses on the financial success of facebook more than the social part so i would not necessarily use it as a source in a paper about social networking.

http://topics.nytimes.com/top/news/business/companies/facebook_inc/index.html

Journal Article Assessment (Facebook)

Facebook Is Now 200 Million Strong

Published Apr 8, 2009 by KJ Mullins

DigitalJournal.com is a social news site made up of professional journalists, citizen journalists, and bloggers. So i don't know if it would be a great source to use since you don't really know if the author is just some dude or not. The article is short and not very informative, it just talks about how facebook is 200 million strong and that the founder of facebook was voted The World's Most Influential Person of 2008.Not very exciting and didn't have an opinion in it, just stated facts. This article wouldn't help in writing a paper.

http://www.digitaljournal.com/article/270680

Magazine Article Assessment (Facebook)

Why Facebook Is the Future

By Lev Grossman Thursday, Aug. 23, 2007

(picture from article)

This Time magazine article is all about how social networks (mainly facebook) are changing the way we live. The article brings home the point that social networks like facebook connect people with one another with ease while at the same time keeping them apart. Although it doesn't say it outright the article hints that facebook causes more harm than it does good. The article is titled "Why Facebook is the Future" the future seems dim in the authors eyes. This is an authoritative article because TIME is a respected magazine with pro journalists. It is a good source that gives a lot of information on facebook and social networks. Would be useful in writing a paper on social networks.

http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1655722,00.html

Research Questions

• Narrow the thesis down to a social network like Facebook
  
• how is facebook helping students interact the with world?
• How do they use it?
• Who is using it?
• how is it different than regular leisure activities?
• Are people exploiting it?
• Helpful or hurtful in the long-run?
  

Thesis Statement

Thesis Statement: As new methods of communication have been created by technological advances, social networks are becoming more and more important to how students and the world interact with each other.

Sources that might be helpful in proving this point:

• Wikipedia
• Facebook, myspace, ect.
• online journals
• library
  

Facebook Wikipedia

"Facebook is a free-access social networking website that is operated and privately owned by Facebook, Inc. Users can join networks organized by city, workplace, school, and region to connect and interact with other people." -Wikipedia

The wikipedia on facebook fully explains all aspects of facebook. Its discussion page consist mostly of people talking about Iran banning facebook, and crazy people talking about random stuff. The wikipedia is useful to me and possibly to our social networking paper because facebook is a major component of social networking today and wikipedia gives you an accurate description and history of it.

Social Networking Service Assessment

Social Networking: Facebook


Note details about the entire site & describe briefly
-Facebook has a number of features with which users may interact. They include the "Wall", a space on every user's profile page that allows friends to post messages for the user to see, "Pokes", which allows users to send a virtual "poke" to each other (a notification that tells a user that they have been poked), Photos, where users can upload albums and photos, and "Status", which allows users to inform their friends of their whereabouts and actions. Facebook constantly creates new features for it's users.

Assess how it is used
-Facebook is a free-access social networking website. Users can join networks organized by city, workplace, school, and region to connect and interact with other people. People can also add friends and send them messages, and update their personal profiles to notify friends about themselves. You can use it for finding old school friends and work colleagues who you had lost touch with, and once you found them you are able to contact them with greater ease than other sites. It is big among high school and college students too. They can contact and/or communicate instantly with friends by just being on the computer.

Assess who uses it (based on the other users)
-High school and college kids probably make up most of its users. The youngsters of today are now supposedly the 'facebook generation', meaning that they prefer to spend the majority of their time communicating with their 'friends' online than in person.

Assess what it represents to the users
-It represents your own "space" on the Internet in which you can customize to you're liking. Its a place to talk with friends and network. It has become "the cool thing to have" because "everyone has one." Like any innovative website the media were quick to jump on the facebook phenomenon, which helped feed interest in facebook, as increasing numbers of people signed up to see what all the fuss was about. The Internet through sites like facebook and myspace are becoming the main way of communication.

Assess if it's useful or not (and answer the why or why not)
-It is useful because you can catch up with old friends and are able to make new 'friends' whilst being entertained with the games and other downloads it provides. Its a source of entertainment and social networking that makes it easier to make and keep in contact with friends. It connects millions with one another.

Assess if private information about a user is apparent
-There are security setting you can make to restrict strangers from viewing your profile. So the information you wish to share is totally up to you. If you block someone, they will not be able to find you in a Facebook search, see your profile, or interact with you through Facebook channels (such as Wall posts, Poke, etc.). You can set your profile to "My network and friends", "Everyone", "Friends of Friends", and "Only Friends." These allow you to pretty much control what people get to see. It seems to be pretty secure.

assessing technology article

Isolated Community: Hidden Dangers of MMORPG's
Rachel Schofield

People play these games because they are either just bored or are not happy with their lives. Its a second life for them in which they can be and do anything they want. For some it becomes incredibly addicting and people can waste their whole life in this fantasy world. People that play these games seem to neglect their family and friends to further advance themselves in the game. It also gives them the chance to connect with other players and compete.

assessing 3 sources

http://consumerist.com/5150175/facebooks-new-terms-of-service-we-can-do-anything-we-want-with-your-content-forever

This source used alot of quotes by the facebook terms of agreement itself to illustrate the authors opinion on the new terms of agreement. The author didn't so much critique it than just highlight certain aspects of it to make the reader think. This is a good source because most of it is taken from the actual terms of agreement.

http://creativecommons.org/weblog/entry/12778

This source gave a one-sided view of the new terms of agreement for facebook. The author talked about how the "CC" is working for peoples best interest to make sure they understand what is going on, like with the new facebook. It was boring. It didn't have that much detail on what the "CC" was so i wouldn't use it as a source.

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/years/2009/0217092samsung1.html

This website pokes fun at social events and news, it's purpose is for entertainment only so it wouldn't be a great source to use unless you wanted to prove a sarcastic point. I found it to be pretty funny.